Carrie Underwood Joins American Idol Season 23 as New Judge – First Former Winner to Serve on Panel

A historic change is set to take place in the 2025 season of America’s iconic talent show “American Idol.” Carrie Underwood, winner of Season 4 in 2004, is returning as a judge after a 20-year absence. This marks the first time in American Idol’s history that a former winner has taken a seat on the judging panel. Carrie Underwood will serve alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, with long-time host Ryan Seacrest handling the show’s presentation. Craig Erwich, president of Disney Television Group, stated in a release that “Carrie, as a former winner and a dynamic music icon, will bring a unique perspective to one of America’s most popular programs,” adding, “Welcome back, Carrie.” Season 23 is scheduled to air on ABC at 8 a.m. on March 9. Prior to that, a special preview will be broadcast on March 2 following the 97th Academy Awards, offering viewers about 30 minutes of footage showing Carrie’s first moments in her new role as well as early audition scenes. Lionel Richie, Luke Bryan, and Katy Perry have served as judges since 2019, but Katy Perry announced she would leave after Season 22 in February 2024. Following the finale of Season 22 in May 2024, the network began preparing for the new season by revealing a fresh lineup of judges. Abby Carter, the most recent American Idol winner, released her debut album and went on tour after winning in May 2024, and now auditions have begun to find the next great talent.